Signals from Ramp spend data
Good morning (hopefully),
Last week was weird. From the nationwide ground stop to the Microsoft outage and all the Nvidia drama, folks are speculating about cyberattacks, aliens, and whether everything is broken. Nvidia’s earnings call today should be interesting.
In today’s letter:
- Three signals from our unreleased spend report
- Could SpaceXAI be the next Anthropic?
- AI spend per employee more than doubles
📣 We’re hiring a freelance video producer and editor to turn our data-driven stories into engaging short videos for social media, and we’re announcing the role here first. If you’re interested, check out the job description or share it with your social-savvy friends (or forward this email).
Top signals from our Winter Spending Report
We’re giving our readers early access to some of the top data points from our latest Business Spending Report, which will be released soon.
Few datasets track business AI adoption, and when they do, they’re based on surveys that are often disconnected from actual business behavior.
Our AI Index uses real transaction data: aggregated and anonymized card and bill pay spend from more than 85,000 U.S. businesses on Ramp. Let’s get into the signals:
1. AI adoption is widespread, but the pace is easing

Nearly 56% of Ramp businesses now pay for AI tools and services, up 1.1 percentage points from July. But adoption growth has slowed, suggesting we may be at the top of the S-curve.
And while token usage spiked, in August and September we saw two straight months of virtually no growth in token spend. Token prices have fallen as providers compete on price, underscoring the importance of tracking usage alongside cost.
2. AI now accounts for a meaningful share of business spending

Purchases of AI tools and services reached 5.8% of Ramp business spend excluding payroll in September, compared with 0.8% in July 2023, showing how far AI budgets have expanded.
Businesses are increasingly relying on AI tools and services, both for internal and customer-facing work (think: customer support bots).
3. AI model relationships are increasingly fluid

There’s still very little loyalty in the AI model space.
The three-month average share of firms whose top model provider changed, measured by token spend, reached a record 8% in September. As providers compete, businesses are increasingly reallocating their token spend.
Could SpaceXAI be the next Anthropic?

Last month, SpaceXAI’s business adoption growth significantly outpaced that of Anthropic and OpenAI.
Ramp economist Ara Kharazian predicts the two-way AI race will quickly turn into a three-way race that puts greater price pressure on OpenAI and Anthropic:
“In October, SpaceXAI led breakout growth in business AI adoption. Among Ramp businesses, 6.3% paid SpaceXAI, up 2.2 percentage points from last month. Anthropic adoption rose 1.1 percentage points to 44.8%, while OpenAI adoption held flat at 40.6%.
SpaceXAI could be the next Anthropic and rapidly climb the charts in business adoption.”
See more signals from Ramp Economics Lab.
AI spending per employee has ~2.5X’d this year

Among U.S. firms on Ramp paying for AI, median monthly spend per employee rose from $6.32 in January to $15.70 in September.
Signals Shortlist
- Nvidia board is not considering bringing Jensen Huang back as CEO, source says (CNBC)
- Who could replace Jensen Huang? A highly unscientific list of possible successors (TechCrunch)
- JPMorgan Chase says temporary software bug is affecting consumer banking (CNBC)
- Nationwide ground stop ripples into third day of canceled flights (Wall Street Journal)
- Fed's Collins says gradual rate hikes best to manage economic risks (Reuters)
🗓️ Leading Events:
Tuesday, November 17: Retail sales. Earnings expected from Nvidia, Disney, Home Depot, Klarna, and JD.com
Wednesday, November 18: Earnings expected from Target, Lowe’s, TJX, and Tencent
Thursday, November 19: Fed meeting minutes.Earnings expected from Walmart, Intuit, Alibaba, NetEase, Warner Music Group, Valvoline, GAP, Ross, Webull, and Post Holdings
Friday, November 20: University of Michigan consumer sentiment (final). Earnings expected from BJ’s Wholesale
🤝 Like what you read? Share Leading Indicators with a friend.


