How to do a Supplier Audit for Procurement

Have you ever faced unexpected delays in receiving materials from a supplier, throwing off your entire production schedule? You're not alone.  Research shows that companies with better supply chain management strategies face far fewer disruptions. In fact, they experience only about one-third as many problems as other businesses do.

‍

A supplier audit is an essential evaluation process that helps you examine your suppliers' capabilities, performance, and compliance to ensure they meet your business standards and requirements.

‍

Neglecting to conduct thorough audits can lead to significant consequences, such as quality issues, delivery delays, and even legal problems—all of which can damage your business reputation and bottom line. 

‍

This article will explore how to effectively prepare and execute supplier audits, what to look out for, and the best practices to ensure your supply chain remains robust and reliable.

‍

Importance of supplier audits

‍

These audits help you identify vulnerabilities, ensure adherence to standards, and improve communication with your suppliers.

‍

Conducting regular supplier audits is essential for:

‍

Quality Assurance: Audits ensure that your suppliers meet your quality standards, helping you maintain product consistency and reliability. This is particularly important in pharmaceuticals, automotive, and aerospace industries, where quality and safety are paramount.

‍

Risk Mitigation: Supplier audits serve as an early warning system for potential issues in your supply chain. By thoroughly examining your suppliers' operations, you can spot risks before they turn into costly problems. This proactive approach helps prevent production delays, quality issues, and reputational damage.

‍

During audits, consider factors like financial stability, capacity constraints, and business continuity plans. Consider creating a risk scorecard for each supplier based on audit findings, allowing you to prioritize high-risk vendors for more frequent checks or corrective actions.

‍

Efficiency and Communication: Supplier audits do more than check quality; they create a foundation for smoother operations and clearer communication throughout your supply chain. By reviewing, you can identify bottlenecks and inefficiencies that may be slowing down production or increasing costs.

‍

Customer Satisfaction: Regular supplier audits are crucial in maintaining high customer satisfaction. By thoroughly checking your suppliers, you ensure they consistently deliver top-quality products or services. This approach helps to prevent issues before they reach your customers, reducing complaints and returns.

‍

Regulatory Compliance: If suppliers don't follow these rules, your company could face big fines or even lose its license to operate. Regular audits help ensure your suppliers meet all necessary regulations. This protects your business from legal trouble and keeps your reputation intact.

‍

How to conduct supplier quality audit

‍

Step 1: Preparation and planning

‍

To conduct an effective supplier audit, clearly define your objectives, such as verifying compliance or assessing product quality. These goals will guide your entire process.

‍

Next, select a competent audit team with relevant expertise, ideally including members from various departments for a comprehensive perspective. Develop a detailed audit plan and checklist that outlines the scope, areas to review, and evaluation criteria. This ensures a systematic and thorough audit.

Communicate with the supplier about the upcoming audit, its purpose, and what's required from them. This sets clear expectations and promotes cooperation, making the audit process smoother and more effective.

‍

Step 2: Gathering information

‍

Start your supplier audit preparation by reviewing key documentation, including quality manuals, process flows, SOPs, and previous audit reports. This review provides valuable insights into the supplier's operations and compliance history, helping you identify areas needing closer examination.

‍

Thoroughly understand the supplier's processes, including production methods, quality assurance practices, and supply chain management. This knowledge allows you to spot potential risks and improvement areas. 

‍

Plan the audit date with the supplier, making sure important people from both sides can attend. Proper scheduling minimizes disruptions and ensures comprehensive coverage of all relevant areas during the audit.

‍

Step 3: Conducting the audit

‍

Opening meeting

‍

Begin the audit with an opening meeting. This meeting introduces the auditors to the supplier's key staff and senior management. During this session, review the audit's purpose and scope, agree on communication methods, and clarify the audit plan.

‍

Address any ambiguities from the pre-audit questionnaire. Additionally, the supplier can outline their policies regarding safety, photography, confidentiality, sample collection, and interactions with staff.

‍

Facility tour

‍

After the opening meeting, conduct a thorough tour of the facility. This tour allows you to observe operations directly, assess the cleanliness and condition of the facilities, and evaluate any risks of contamination. It also helps you understand the scale and capacity of the supplier's operations.

‍

Evidence gathering

‍

Gather relevant evidence throughout the audit. This involves observing processes, questioning staff, reviewing documentation and records, and addressing any issues of concern. Record all observations clearly and support them with objective evidence. Discuss these observations with the supplier during the audit to prevent surprises during the closing meeting.

‍

Closing meeting

‍

Conclude the audit with a closing meeting. This allows you to present your findings and conclusions to the supplier's management. Share a simple agenda and a brief written summary of your observations. Highlight both strengths and areas needing improvement to provide a balanced view.

‍

Step 4: Analyzing findings

‍

After completing the audit, organize all collected data, including notes, observations, and evidence. This systematic approach helps identify patterns and ensures thoroughness. Then, identify non-conformances by comparing findings against predefined criteria and standards, documenting deviations with specific examples.

‍

Evaluate the supplier's overall performance based on the compiled data and identified non-conformances. Assess how well they meet your quality standards and compliance requirements, considering strengths and weaknesses. This evaluation will guide your final recommendations and decisions regarding the supplier relationship.

Step 5: Reporting and follow-Up

‍

After analyzing the audit findings:

1. Create a detailed report that includes an overview of the process, key observations, and identified non-conformances with supporting evidence.
   
   
2. Share this clear, concise report with the supplier promptly, highlighting strengths and improvement areas.
   
   
3. Develop a corrective action plan with the supplier, outlining specific steps to address each issue and setting realistic deadlines.
   
   
4. Monitor the implementation of these corrective actions and track improvements through regular follow-ups with the supplier.
   
   

This ongoing monitoring ensures continuous improvement and maintains the integrity of your supply chain.

‍

Key indicators to watch during a supplier audit

‍

When conducting a supplier audit, it's essential to identify and address critical issues that could impact your supply chain's reliability and quality.

‍

1. Unusual financial discrepancies

‍

Look for inconsistencies in financial records, unexplained cash flow variances, or significant revenue or expenses changes that lack clear explanations. These discrepancies can signal mismanagement or potential fraud. Investigate any irregularities thoroughly to understand their root causes.

‍

2. Lack of documentation or incomplete records

‍

Ensure the supplier provides all necessary documents and that records are complete and well-maintained. Missing or poorly kept records can indicate attempts to hide information or weak internal controls. Reliable documentation is crucial for verifying compliance and operational integrity.

‍

3. Overly complex or unusual transactions

‍

Pay attention to transactions that deviate from normal business operations, such as unusual contracts, complex financial instruments, or dealings with related parties. These can obscure the supplier's financial status and may require detailed scrutiny to uncover hidden risks.

‍

4. High employee turnover in key roles

‍

Frequent changes in critical positions, particularly in finance and quality control, can disrupt internal processes and hint at deeper issues within the supplier's organization. High turnover might indicate a problematic work environment or efforts to mask unethical practices.

‍

5. Inconsistencies between reports and operational reality

‍

Compare financial reports with the actual operational conditions observed during the audit. Discrepancies, such as reports showing growth while the company struggles with cash flow or customer retention, warrant further investigation. These inconsistencies can reveal underlying problems not reflected in the documentation.

‍

6. Resistance or lack of cooperation during the audit

‍

Notice any resistance or reluctance from the supplier's management or staff. Delays in providing information, evading questions, or a general lack of transparency can be red flags. Such behavior often indicates that the supplier might be concealing issues that require attention.

‍

Mitigating a failed supplier audit

‍

When a supplier audit reveals significant issues, begin by thoroughly assessing the findings and understanding root causes, maintaining open communication with the supplier.

‍

Collaboratively develop and implement a Corrective Action Plan (CAP) that addresses each non-conformance with specific actions, responsible parties, and realistic deadlines.

‍

Continuously monitor and verify the CAP's effectiveness through regular progress checks and follow-up audits. Offer ongoing support to help the supplier maintain high standards, fostering a long-term partnership based on trust and continuous improvement.

‍

Types of supplier audits

‍

Quality system audit

‍

A Quality System Audit assesses the effectiveness and efficiency of a supplier's management systems. This audit examines the processes and procedures to ensure consistent quality across all operations.

‍

It looks at how well the supplier's quality management system (QMS) adheres to international standards, such as ISO 9001. The focus is on identifying areas for improvement within the system to enhance overall performance and reliability.

‍

Process audit

‍

A Product Audit involves examining finished products to ensure they meet predefined specifications and quality standards. This audit checks for compliance with design, performance, and safety requirements.

‍

It helps detect defects and inconsistencies in the final products, ensuring that only high-quality goods reach the market. This type of audit is crucial for maintaining customer satisfaction and trust.

‍

Product audit

‍

A Product Audit involves the examination of finished products to ensure they meet predefined specifications and quality standards. This audit checks for compliance with design, performance, and safety requirements.

‍

It helps detect defects and inconsistencies in the final products, ensuring that only high-quality goods reach the market. This type of audit is crucial for maintaining customer satisfaction and trust.

‍

Compliance audit

‍

A Compliance Audit ensures that a supplier aligns with relevant regulations, industry standards, and contractual obligations. This audit checks for adherence to legal requirements, such as environmental regulations, labor laws, and safety standards.

‍

It helps identify non-compliance issues that could result in legal penalties or damage to the company's reputation. Compliance audits are essential for risk management and maintaining regulatory compliance.

‍

Different formats of supplier audits

‍

Supplier audits can be conducted in various ways, each serving a specific purpose and offering unique insights into a supplier's operations and compliance. The following formats illustrate the range of approaches used in modern supplier auditing practices:

‍

Announced audits

‍

These are scheduled in advance, allowing suppliers time to prepare. They are useful for thorough, planned evaluations of the supplier's systems and processes.

‍

Unannounced audits

‍

These occur without prior notice, providing a real-time snapshot of the supplier's operations. They are effective for assessing everyday practices and identifying any hidden issues.

‍

Desktop audits

‍

Conducted remotely, these audits review documentation and records rather than on-site operations. They are useful for initial assessments, follow-ups, and when on-site visits are not feasible.

‍

Conclusion

‍

By following a structured audit process, you can identify areas for improvement, develop corrective actions, and foster strong supplier relationships.

‍

Want to make your audits even better? Try using Ramp.

With Ramp, you can easily handle all your buying requests. You'll control your spending from the start and automate your buying process. Ramp puts all your requests in one place, making it easy for you to work with your team. You'll see your spending in real-time and get automatic approvals. This helps you catch problems early and work faster. Ramp's AI tools can boost how you manage your suppliers and audits.

‍

By leveraging Ramp, you can take your supplier audits and procurement management to the next level, ensuring efficiency, compliance, and strategic oversight across your supply chain. Explore how Ramp can support your business needs and drive continuous improvement in your supplier management practices →

‍

‍