1099 vs. W-2: A guide for employers

‍

A 1099 tax form is used to report payments made to independent contractors or self-employed individuals. On the other hand, a W-2 tax form is used by employers to report wages paid to employees and the taxes withheld from those wages. Both forms serve essential roles in tax reporting, but their use depends on how a worker is classified. 

‍

The IRS has a detailed guide to help figure out if someone is an employee or contractor. This choice affects tax rates, benefits, and how they work together.

Understanding 1099 and W-2 employee classifications

1099 contractors are self-employed individuals who handle their own taxes and work independently. They’re often hired for specific projects. Meanwhile, W-2 employees are a part of your business, receiving regular wages and tax withholdings managed by the employer.

‍

But how do you know which workers fall under what category? The Internal Revenue Service has defined three factors that will help you classify your workers:

• Behavioral control: Focuses on whether you control how the worker performs their job. This includes training, supervision, and specific instructions on when, where, and how tasks are completed. 
• Financial control: Examines who handles the financial aspects of the job. Factors include who provides tools and equipment, covers business expenses, and whether the worker has the opportunity to profit or incur losses.
• Type of relationship: This looks at the nature of your working relationship. A long-term arrangement with employee benefits suggests W-2 status. A project-based or temporary engagement without benefits aligns with the 1099 classification.

Key differences between 1099 and W-2 employees

When you understand that your worker falls under the W-2 or 1099 category, you can calculate your taxes much better, get the hang of benefits, and better manage your team. 

‍

‍

Pros and cons of hiring 1099 contractors

When you bring in a 1099 contractor, you have complete flexibility over work distribution. You can bring in contractors for specific projects or short-term tasks. This is especially helpful if your workload changes throughout the year. You only pay for the work they complete without covering any benefits or protections. On average, this can save employers up to 30% on labor costs.

‍

Contractors are workers who also offer specialized skills. Instead of spending time and money training a full-time employee, you can hire someone with the exact expertise you need. This is particularly useful for tasks like IT consulting or creative projects.

‍

While 1099 contractors offer you flexibility, it also means that you'll have less degree of control over how and when they work as they operate independently. This can make integrating them into your company's workflow or meeting tight deadlines harder.

‍

Contractors also often work for multiple clients. This means they may not always be available when you need them. If you rely on contractors for ongoing tasks, it could cost more than hiring a full-time employee.

Pros and cons of hiring W-2 workers

With W-2 workers, you get more control over your workforce. You decide their schedules, assign tasks, and oversee their performance. This level of control makes W-2 workers ideal for roles that require consistency and long-term dedication.

‍

These workers also bring stability to your business. They are part of your team and usually have set hours, which helps with long-term planning. They also enjoy job security and benefits like minimum wage, health insurance, retirement plans, and paid leave. Offering these perks can help you retain employees.

‍

However, hiring W-2 employees can be costly over time. You must cover payroll taxes, including Social Security and Medicare, and expenses for benefits and equipment. These added costs make full-time employees more expensive than contractors.

‍

Managing W-2 employees also involves more paperwork and compliance. You’ll need to handle payroll, meet federal tax filing deadlines, and manage benefit programs. If you have 250 or more W-2s, you’ll have to file them electronically, adding another step to your administrative duties.

Compliance and tax considerations

Compliance protects your company and keeps you legally secure as a business owner. If you misclassify your employees as contractors, you might face penalties, back taxes, and legal issues. The IRS also closely monitors classifications because they impact the tax collection process.

Tax responsibilities for 1099 contractors

As we have discussed, when you hire 1099 contractors, they are in charge of their own taxes. Your contractors will receive full payment for their work and are responsible for handling their tax obligations.

‍

You can process these invoices easily with Ramp's accounts payable option. It sets up smart approval workflows and alerts you to potential errors or overbilling. This helps you ensure payments are accurate and on time. 

‍

Contractors must report all taxable income to the IRS, even if they work for multiple small businesses. If you pay a contractor $600 or more in a year, you need to provide them with a 1099-NEC form by January 31. This form helps them report their income, but they're required to report any earnings, even below $600, whether or not a form is issued.

‍

They also pay self-employment taxes, which cover Social Security and Medicare. The rate for these taxes is 15.3%, combining both the employee and employer portions. They can deduct the employer portion of self-employment taxes on their personal tax returns.

‍

Contractors are responsible for federal income taxes and, in some cases, state taxes. To stay compliant, they often make quarterly estimated tax payments to avoid underpayment penalties. 

‍

Your role as an employer is simple: provide accurate and timely 1099 forms to your contractors. 

Tax responsibilities for W-2 workers

When you hire W-2 employees, you take on several tax responsibilities. For every paycheck, you need to withhold federal income tax based on the information provided on your employee's W-4 form. 

‍

You also withhold Social Security and Medicare taxes, known as FICA taxes, which total 7.65% of their wages. As the employer, you match this amount. For example, if an employee earns $50,000 a year, your share of FICA would be $3,825.

‍

In many cases, you also need to withhold and pay state and local income taxes. Some states require you to pay into unemployment insurance programs, which help employees in case of job loss. These payments are your responsibility and are separate from the employee's contributions.

‍

At the end of the year, you must provide a W-2 form to each employee by January 31. This form reports their earnings and tax withholdings for the year. You're also required to file copies with the Social Security Administration (SSA).

Financial implications for employers

Whether you hire a 1099 contractor or a W-2 employee, your choice will directly impact your costs and budgeting strategy. The financial implications go far beyond wages, influencing everything from tax obligations to long-term operational expenses.

Payroll costs: 1099 vs. W-2

For W-2 employees, payroll involves more than writing a paycheck. You must establish and maintain a payroll system to calculate and withhold taxes, file tax returns, and issue forms like W-2s and W-3s. These additional steps make W-2 employment more labor-intensive and costly from an administrative perspective. With 1099 contractors, payroll is far simpler. Payments go directly to the contractor, and no deductions or tax filings are required. 

Benefits and insurance costs

The benefits you offer to your W-2 employees can increase your labor costs by 20-30% of an employee's salary. For instance, if an employee earns $60,000 annually, you may spend an additional $12,000 to $18,000 on benefits. Health insurance is one of the biggest expenses, with employers paying an average of $6,584 per year for single coverage.

‍

You're also responsible for workers' compensation insurance. This cost depends on your state and industry and typically ranges from 0.5% to over 3% of payroll, depending on job risk. 

‍

On the other hand, when you hire 1099 contractors, you avoid all these costs. While this reduces your expenses, contractors often charge higher rates to cover these expenses themselves. 

‍

The contractor's industry, skill level, and demand for their expertise also influence their rates. Specialized professionals, such as IT consultants or creative freelancers, often charge premium rates, especially for short-term projects or urgent assignments.

‍

Switching between 1099 and W-2 employment

You might consider switching a contractor to an employee if their responsibilities become more integral to your operations or require a long-term commitment. Similarly, you might move an employee to contractor status if the work becomes more project-based, independent, or short-term in nature. 

Switching from 1099 contractor to W-2 employee

You should start by reviewing their role to assess how their work has changed. If you now control when, where, or how they work, or if you provide tools and training, they likely qualify as a W-2 employee. Next, you'll need to update their written contract by ending the contractor arrangement and issuing an employment offer letter. This letter should outline their salary, benefits, and job expectations. 

‍

Once that's done, onboard the worker by collecting a W-4 form for tax purposes and adding them to your payroll system. You'll also need to enroll them in any eligible benefits, such as health insurance or retirement plans. 

Switching from W-2 employee to 1099 contractor

Before making this transition, you must confirm that the worker meets the IRS criteria for independent contractors, which include controlling their work schedule and operating independently. Next, you must formally end the W-2 employment relationship by processing any final wages and benefits and providing a termination letter. 

‍

Once the employment relationship is closed, create a new contractor agreement that clearly outlines the scope of work, payment terms, and expectations for independence. Finally, you must adjust the payment process to reflect their contractor status. 

Make smarter hiring decisions with the right worker classification

By classifying your workers correctly, you protect your finances while ensuring legal compliance. Misclassifying your workers can lead to penalties of up to $1,000 per worker, along with interest on unpaid taxes. 

‍

When you properly classify your workers, you can also better allocate your resources. W-2 employees may cost more upfront, but they provide stability and continuity. On the other hand, 1099 contractors can save you money on payroll and benefits for short-term or specialized tasks.

‍