eCheck vs. ACH: What’s the difference and which one should you choose?

Your business has options when it comes to what form of payment to use to pay vendors. It’s important to understand what those options are and how they differ so you can make the best choice possible.

‍

eChecks and ACH payments are both widely used for transferring funds between bank accounts. While they may seem similar, their differences can impact how efficiently your accounts payable (AP) team processes transactions.

‍

Let’s break down the key differences and similarities between eChecks and ACH payments so you can always choose the best option for your business.

What are eCheck payments?

‍

By combining the familiarity of traditional checks with the speed and efficiency of digital payments, eChecks provide a faster, more reliable way to send and receive money. Businesses and consumers commonly use them for bill payments, online purchases, payroll deposits, and recurring transactions.

How do eCheck payments work?

eCheck payments follow a structured process to ensure secure, reliable transactions and are generally used for one-off payments. Here’s how they work:

1. Authorization: You provide your bank account number and bank routing number in a secure payment portal or checkout system. Vendors must obtain explicit consent before processing the transaction, usually via a checkbox or digital agreement.
2. Verification: The payment processor verifies the payment information, ensuring sufficient funds and scanning for fraud or mismatches. Some systems debit and refund a small amount to confirm account validity.
3. Transmission: Once verified, the payment details are securely transmitted through the ACH network for processing. ACH transactions process in batches, keeping costs low and ensuring reliable settlement within 1–3 business days.
4. Processing: Your bank withdraws the payment amount and transfers it to the vendor’s account. Both banks finalize the transaction and update account balances.
5. Notification: Once the payment is complete, both you and the vendor receive confirmation. The vendor gets a payment receipt, while you receive an email with transaction details such as ID, amount, and date.

‍

Now that we’ve covered what eCheck payments are and how they work, let’s look at ACH payments. 

What are ACH payments?

ACH payments are electronic transfers that move funds between bank accounts through the ACH network. This system processes billions of transactions annually and plays a critical role in business payments, payroll, and bill payments.

‍

ACH transactions are governed by Nacha (formerly the National Automated Clearing House Association) and fall into two main types:

• ACH credit transactions: ACH credits allow you to push funds to another account. Common use cases include direct deposits and vendor payments.
• ACH debit transactions: ACH debits let vendors pull funds from your account after obtaining authorization. These transactions are ideal for recurring bill payments and loan payments.

‍

Breaking down how the ACH payment process works can give you a better understanding of what ACH payments are.

How do ACH payments work?

Like eCheck payments, ACH payments follow a structured process to securely and efficiently transfer funds. But while eChecks are more for one-time payments, ACH payments are often used for recurring payments. Here’s how they work:

1. Initiation: You provide the recipient’s bank account information and routing number and the payment amount. Then, you specify the transaction type: credit or debit. 
2. Request hits Originating Depository Financial Institution (ODFI): The request goes to the ODFI (the sender’s bank), which compiles the payment data into a standardized file and verifies the details before submitting it to the ACH network
3. Batch processing: Instead of processing payments one at a time, the ODFI groups multiple transactions into batches and submits them at scheduled intervals. This is more efficient and cost-effective.
4. ACH operator: The ACH operator (either the Federal Reserve or Electronic Payments Network) acts as an intermediary, sorting and routing transactions to the correct recipient banks for processing
5. Receiving Depository Financial Institution (RDFI) processing: The RDFI (recipient’s bank) processes the transaction by debiting your account for the ACH debit
6. Settlement: With the transactions verified, banks reconcile balances through a central clearinghouse. After settlement, the banks update both account balances and both parties receive payment confirmation.

‍

Now that we’ve covered what eChecks and ACH payments are and how they work, let’s look at how they compare.

eChecks vs. ACH payments: Key differences compared

Understanding the key differences between eChecks and ACH payments can help you determine which is best for your business. Here's are their main differences compared:

‍

‍

While eChecks and ACH payments differ in certain ways, they also share several core similarities that make each of them secure, cost-effective alternatives to traditional payment methods.

Similarities between eCheck and ACH payments

Despite their differences, both eChecks and ACH payments function as electronic alternatives to traditional paper checks, offering your business an efficient way to transfer funds. Here’s what they have in common:

• Electronic transfers: Both eliminate the need for physical checks, enabling faster, paperless transactions
• Cost savings: Compared to credit card payments, both methods reduce processing costs, making them more affordable 
• Security and compliance: Each follows strict financial regulations to protect sensitive data. eChecks use digital signatures and encryption, while ACH transactions comply with Nacha security standards.
• ACH network processing: Both rely on the ACH network, ensuring secure, standardized transaction processing across financial institutions
• Broad business acceptance: eChecks and ACH payments are widely used across industries for B2C and B2B transactions, making them both versatile payment options

‍

Both methods offer security, efficiency, and cost savings, making either choice a valuable payment solution depending on your business’s specific needs. Understanding the similarities and differences can help you determine which method aligns best with your operational goals.

Regulatory compliance for eChecks and ACH payments

Following compliance regulations is essential to avoid penalties, protect customer data, and ensure smooth transactions. Here’s how your business can stay compliant when using either ACH payments or eCheck payments.

For ACH payments

ACH transactions must comply with the following Nacha regulations, designed to ensure payments are processed securely and efficiently:

• Authorization requirements: Businesses must obtain clear and explicit payment authorization from customers, whether written, electronic, or verbal, and must keep records for at least two years for potential audits or disputes
• Transaction limits: Some consumer accounts have Nacha-enforced transaction caps to reduce fraud risks. Knowing these limits can help prevent processing issues.
• Data security: Businesses must protect financial data by using platforms that comply with Payment Card Industry Data Security Standard (PCI DSS) regulations and employ encryption or tokenization for security
• Processing deadlines: ACH transactions follow strict processing timeframes. Staying compliant ensures timely and predictable payments, improving cash flow.

‍

These regulations result in safer, more efficient transactions for your business. 

For eChecks

eChecks are regulated by federal laws such as the Uniform Commercial Code (UCC) and the Electronic Fund Transfer Act (EFTA), which ensure security and transparency:

• Authorization and consent: Every eCheck transaction requires payer consent, typically obtained through a digital signature or electronic agreement
• Fraud prevention: Identity verification measures such as multi-factor authentication (MFA) or tokenization protect against fraud while keeping transactions compliant
• Dispute resolution: Federal law provides a structured process for dispute resolution. Businesses must respond within given timelines to maintain compliance.
• Transparency: Customers must receive clear transaction details upfront, including fees, processing times, and refund policies

‍

Maintaining regulatory compliance is critical for staying on the right side of the law. It also ensures more efficient transactions and builds trust between your business and the companies you do business with.

‍

Now that you know how to use both eChecks and ACH payments, let’s go over some basic steps you can follow when trying to decide between the two.

Choosing the right payment method for your business

Which payment method you choose depends on your business goals, customer preferences, operational priorities, and the nature of your transactions. Here’s how to determine the best fit:

1. Assess your payment frequency

ACH payments offer automated, reliable processing if your business relies on recurring transactions—such as subscriptions, payroll, or monthly bills. For large, one-time payments like real estate transactions or high-value vendor invoices, eChecks may be the better option.

2. Consider processing speed

Payment timelines impact cash flow and business operations. ACH payments can be processed same-day for urgent payouts, while eChecks take up to five business days due to additional verification. If speed is a priority, ACH payments are the better choice.

3. Evaluate cost efficiency

Both methods are more affordable than credit cards, but cost-effectiveness depends on transaction volume. ACH payments are best for high-volume, lower-value transactions due to their lower fees. Despite slightly higher per-transaction costs, eChecks are a convenient option for occasional, high-value transactions.

4. Consider vendor expectations

Vendor preferences can impact payment success. Some prefer eChecks for large payments, as they feel more secure using a familiar check-based system. Others favor ACH for automated, recurring transactions like subscriptions or bill payments.

‍

Surveying vendors or analyzing past payment trends can help you align payment methods with vendor expectations.

5. Align with your operational goals

Your business model and scalability goals will influence your choice:

• If efficiency and automation matter, ACH payments streamline workflows and support business growth
• If simplicity is the goal, eChecks provide a straightforward alternative without complex setup requirements

‍

Regardless of your choice, optimizing payment processes improves cash flow and saves your accounts payable team time. 

Automate your payments with ACH and Ramp

Both eChecks and ACH payments can be a great way to pay your invoices, with the best choice depending on your goals and the type of transaction. If you've chosen to use ACH to save your business time and money and improve vendor relationships with timely payments, Ramp Bill Pay can help you streamline the process.

‍

Ramp Bill Pay, our AP automation software, streamlines the payment process by integrating ACH payments with your AP workflows. Your AP team can reclaim the time spent on manual busywork and gain real-time visibility into every step of the payment cycle.

‍

Ramp Bill Pay provides:

• Customizable approval workflows that keep invoices moving quickly toward payment
• Invoice processing automation and one-click syncing with your ERP
• Automated 2-way and 3-way matching to catch errors quickly and easily before you pay

‍

How much time and money could your AP team save by processing ACH payments on Ramp? Try Ramp Bill Pay and see for yourself.