How a Procurement Process Audit Works

Even the biggest companies can fall prey to different kinds of fraud. For example, a single fraudster tricked Facebook and Google out of over $100 million over a few years. To avoid such pitfalls, you need a robust procurement audit process.

‍

You might think this could not happen to your business, especially if you're not a large tech firm. However, fraud is surprisingly common, even for smaller businesses with fewer than 100 employees.

‍

A procurement audit avoids many of the things that could go wrong, serving as a safeguard against potential issues and irregularities. It helps maintain purchasing compliance, create efficient buying processes, and identify any irregularities or potential fraud. This process is essential for any business that wants to manage spending effectively and build reliable supplier relationships.

‍

This article will explain the step-by-step process to conduct an effective procurement audit, ensuring your business stays compliant and efficient.

Goals of a procurement audit

‍

A procurement audit can potentially bring numerous benefits to your business. Here are the key objectives of an effective procurement audit:

‍

Identify Supplier Inconsistencies: Uncover any discrepancies or issues with suppliers to ensure reliability and quality.

‍

Prevent Fraudulent Activity: Detect and prevent fraud to protect your business from financial losses and reputational damage.

‍

Ensure Compliance: Stay aligned with government regulations and trading compliance standards to avoid fines and legal issues.

‍

Improve Workflows: Identify areas for improvement in your procurement processes to enhance efficiency and productivity.

‍

Optimize Cost-Effectiveness: Access the most cost-effective trading relationships by securing the best vendor prices while maintaining compliance. This helps prevent lost business due to fines or damaged reputations.

‍

Procurement process audit steps

‍

Step 1: Planning and preparation

‍

Start your procurement audit with thorough planning and preparation. To ensure a comprehensive perspective, begin by involving key managers, stakeholders, and possibly external auditors. Their insights can be valuable in understanding different aspects of your procurement process.

‍

Define clear audit objectives. Are you looking to identify weaknesses in your procurement process or assess compliance with regulations? Knowing your goals will help focus the audit and make it more effective.

‍

Establish a timeline to keep the audit on track, ensuring each phase is completed within a reasonable timeframe. Allocate necessary resources, such as personnel and tools, to support the audit process.

‍

Step 2: Reviewing documentation

‍

After planning and preparation, move on to reviewing all the documentation. This step involves gathering and analyzing all the documents related to your procurement process. Start by collecting contracts, vendor records, and any other relevant paperwork. These documents are important for understanding your business's agreements and relationships with its suppliers.

‍

Carefully audit requisition and purchasing forms. Look for any signs of fraudulent activity, such as irregularities or record inconsistencies. This can help identify potential issues before they escalate into bigger problems.

‍

Step 3: Vendor management and selection audit

‍

Evaluate your vendor ecosystem and selection processes. Analyze vendor performance metrics, including delivery times, quality of goods or services, and responsiveness. Assess the diversity of your supplier base and identify any over-reliance on single vendors.

‍

Review your vendor onboarding process, ensuring it includes thorough background checks, financial stability assessments, and alignment with your company's values and sustainability goals. Examine your vendor contract terms to ensure they protect your interests and include appropriate performance clauses and exit strategies.

‍

Step 4: Analyzing procurement processes, compliance, and controls

‍

Map out your entire procurement workflow, from requisition to payment. Identify manual processes that could be automated to increase efficiency. Evaluate the integration of your procurement systems with other business functions like finance and inventory management.

‍

Assess the adoption and effectiveness of e-procurement tools, spend analysis software, and supplier relationship management platforms. Consider emerging technologies like AI-powered spend analytics or blockchain for supply chain transparency. Determine if your team has the necessary skills to leverage these technologies effectively.

‍

Step 5: Identifying risks and solutions

‍

Develop a comprehensive risk matrix specific to your procurement function. This should include geopolitical risks, supply chain disruptions, cybersecurity threats, and regulatory changes. Implement a robust due diligence process for high-risk or high-value contracts. 

‍

Create a compliance scorecard to track adherence to internal policies and external regulations. Establish a whistleblowing mechanism for reporting procurement irregularities. Design and implement regular compliance training programs tailored to different roles within the procurement team. Consider creating a dedicated procurement risk and compliance officer role to oversee these efforts continuously.

‍

Step 6: Reporting and follow-up

‍

The final step in the procurement audit process is reporting and follow-up. Begin by compiling all your findings into a detailed report for senior management and stakeholders. This report should clearly outline the identified issues, risks, and opportunities for improvement.

‍

Based on your findings, recommend specific corrective actions. Ensure these recommendations are practical and actionable. It’s important to track the implementation of these recommendations to verify that they are being followed and to assess their effectiveness over time.

‍

Communicate the audit results with all relevant stakeholders. Make sure everyone understands the findings and their roles in addressing the issues. Follow up regularly to verify compliance and ensure that the recommended actions are making a positive impact.

‍

Procurement audit best practices

‍

• Keep all purchase records up-to-date and accurate, checking them regularly against financial reports and inventory.
  
  

• Regularly train staff on buying policies and how to prevent fraud, using real examples and updating the training when policies change.
  
  
• Use software that works with your current systems to make processes easier and more accurate, with features like automatic approvals and detailed reports.
  
  
• Split up buying tasks among staff members so no one person controls the whole process, reducing the risk of mistakes or fraud.
  
  
• Do surprise checks on different parts of the process to find any problems, using tools to spot unusual activities.
  
  
• Compare how you procure things to other companies in your industry to find ways to improve, and join groups to learn about new ideas.
  
  
• Hire outside experts every few years to check your buying process and give you new ideas on how to make it better.
  
  
• Write down all your buying steps in detail, keep them up-to-date, and make sure everyone can access them.
  
  
• Keep an eye on market changes and use this information to make better procurement decisions and deals.
  
  
• Create an open environment where staff can easily share concerns about procurement processes, and have a clear plan for dealing with any problems quickly.

‍

How Ramp Helps with Procurement Audits

‍

Ramp streamlines and enhances your procurement audit process through its comprehensive features. With Ramp, you can intake procurement requests using embedded AI, capturing every detail, document, and contract upfront. This ensures all information is readily available for audits, eliminating gaps and discrepancies.

‍

Ramp alerts you to overbilling and invoice variances, helping to identify and prevent fraudulent activities. By setting up threshold tolerances, you can control spend from the beginning, making it easier to stay within budget and policy guidelines.

‍

Ramp automates the entire procure-to-pay process, eliminating approval bottlenecks and preventing out-of-policy spending before it occurs. This automation simplifies the audit process, ensuring all transactions are transparent and traceable.

‍

Centralize all spend requests in one place with Ramp, capturing every detail and gaining early visibility into spend. Custom intake forms and dynamic questions ensure you collect the right information from the start, streamlining documentation and making it easily accessible during audits.

‍

Collaboration is seamless with Ramp. Centralize procurement discussions, comment and tag team members, and reduce time-consuming back-and-forth communications. This centralized approach ensures all stakeholders access the same information, facilitating a smoother audit process.

‍

Accelerate approval cycles with automated workflows that fit your business processes. Route requests to the right approvers, use bidirectional sync with Ironclad for contract reviews, and allow approvals directly in Slack or Teams. This efficiency ensures that your procurement process is always audit-ready.

‍

Gain full visibility into committed spend with Ramp. Automatically generate purchase orders, get a consolidated view of all requests and purchase orders, and match invoices to purchase orders for added control. This comprehensive visibility is crucial for effective auditing, ensuring all financial activities are accurately tracked and recorded.

‍

Streamline your procurement audit process with Ramp. Visit Ramp's procurement page to learn more and get started →

‍

‍